62 Min Released Oct 30, 2018

#150: A Star Is Born, Pt. 1 - George Cukor (1954)

Bradley Cooper’s new A STAR IS BORN remake is a current-day spin on a Hollywood fable that’s been around since the 1930s, about a struggling male star and the young ingenue he pushes toward fame. But its music-industry setting makes it a particularly apt match for George Cukor’s 1954 musical spin on the tale, starring a career-redefining Judy Garland as the titular star to James Mason’s fading one. In this half of our two-part discussion of the films, we dig into the legend and legacy of Cukor’s STAR, piece together what the film lost and gained via studio meddling and reconstruction, and debate the nature of the story’s central tragedy. Plus, by listener request, we give some of our recommendations for first-time film festival-goers.

Please share your comments, thoughts, and questions about any and all of Hollywood’s takes on A STAR IS BORN by sending an email to comments@nextpictureshow.net, or leaving a short voicemail at (773) 234-9730

Outro Music: Judy Garland, “Born In A Trunk”

The Next Picture Show

The Next Picture Show

A biweekly roundtable by the former editorial team of The Dissolve examining how classic films inspire and inform modern movies.

Go To Show Page

More Episodes

The Secret History of the Beatles, with Rob Sheffield

Rolling Stone Music Now

Rob Sheffield, author of the new book Dreaming the Beatles, explains why the Fab Four will be relevant forever

39 Min

May 15, 2017

Diane Kruger

Happy Sad Confused

Diane Kruger, star of “The Bridge,” stops by Josh…

30 Min

Jul 27, 2014

S02, Episode 9: It’s time to go to trial: Will Harris testify?


In a matter of days, the 12 jurors will be seated, the lawyers will make their opening statements, and the murder trial of Justin Ross Harris will begin.

28 Min

Sep 29, 2016